Monday, May 11, 2015

Cameras Can Help Illuminate Injustice, But The Outcome Will (Sadly) Be The Same

In 1955, Money, Mississippi, a 14-year-old Black Boy was killed by two white men for having some interaction with one of their wives in a store.  What that interaction was is still unclear, but some versions of the story say he whistled at the white woman, while others say that he said something sexually suggestive to her.  In any case Emmett Till was not supposed to interact with her at all while he was in that store, in accordance with the unjust southern racial caste system.  His body was later found brutally mangled, beaten and unimaginably disfigured.  Although everyone knew who killed him, they also all knew that there would be no justice for him. 

Fast forward to 2014, and to the video footage of Tamir Rice being gunned down by a white police officer in Cleveland, Ohio.  Look at the footage of Eric Garner being choked to death by a half-dozen cops in New York City in the summer of 2014 for illegally selling single cigarettes.  Before that, consider the audio recording of George Zimmerman as he stalked and later killed Trayvon Martin, defying the instructions of the 911 operator who told him not to pursue Martin.  Look at myriad other similar recorded instances in which unarmed Black Men and Boys have been killed while posing no serious threat to anyone, if posing a threat at all.

Now also look at footage of young white men confronting cops, cursing at them, getting chesty with them, pushing them, yelling at them.  The difference is that the white boys can do that and not only live to joke about it later, but often don’t ever find themselves in handcuffs at all after confronting cops.  In fact, young white men can walk into a movie theater, shoot down and kill a dozen people, and live to stand trial and defend themselves (see James Holmes...Aurora, Colorado).

The fact of the matter is that Black people have been mistreated by police officers (and the white public at large) for centuries…AND WE HAVE ALWAYS KNOWN THIS TO BE THE CASE with and without cameras present to verify it.  Every person, Black, white or other, knew that those two white men killed Emmett Till in 1954.  And those two white men knew that they could kill Till and get away with his murder, AND that it would be fine by their white brethren.  And as if to prove that point, they brazenly gave a full length account of how they murdered Till in Look Magazine, once they’d been acquitted of the murder.

Today, everyone (Black, white and other) knows that the death of Eric Garner, for example, was wrong and the white officers were absolutely excessive and out of order in their take down and subsequent disregard for the health of the man.  Yet, no charges.  And the list of similar cases is unbelievably extensive…from the acquittal of the cops who were videotaped beating Rodney King, to the not guilty verdicts of the cops who killed Amadou Diallo (murdered by cops while standing unarmed on the porch of his home).

What’s my point?  I know that everyone is urging the police officers nationwide to adopt the use of body cameras, as a way of holding police officers accountable.  The fact of the matter is that we NEVER needed cameras for everyone to know when an injustice had been committed at the hands of police – the Emmett Till story highlights that (though the white murderers weren’t cops in that case).

I support all police officers having body cams that have specific fail safes on them (e.g. alerts when a cop turns off the camera, requiring the cop to explain why the camera was off).  But all the cameras will do is add to the ridiculously extensive pile of proof that societal injustices – often at the hands of (white) police officers – frequently occur toward Black people.  But what the very recent evidence shows is that even with cameras the end result will not change:  Black Men will be unnecessarily killed, while white murderers – whether in a badge or not – will go free.


-Maelstrom

No comments: